Australia's Best Cars
Finalists 2008 Previous Results Judging Criteria Judging Panel Your Say Media Login
Previous Results

Previous Results

2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004 | 2003 | 2002 | 2001 | 2000



Best Small Car


Ford Fiesta

Ford Fiesta
1.6-litre
5-speed manual
3-door hatchback
$14,490



Value for Money
Importance
Pricing 4 Critical
Depreciation Cost 4 Medium
Running & Repair 4 Critical
Fuel Consumption 3 Critical
Warranty 3 High
Standard Features 3 Medium



Design & Function

 
Safety 3 Critical
Security 4 High
Environment 3.5 Critical
Comfort 4 Medium
Space 3 Low
Practicality 3 Low
Ergonomics 4 High
Build & Finish Quality 4 Medium



On the Road

 
Performance 4 Medium
Ride 4 Medium
Handling 5 Medium
Braking 4 High
Smoothness/Quietness 3 Low



Overall Average


3.66



Key to Ratings

 
Well Above Average 5 .
Above Average 4 .
Average 3 .
Below Average 2 .
Well Below Average 1 .

Importance Weighting

 
Critical 1.00 .
High 0.80 .
Medium 0.40 .
Low 0.20 .



View Scores for all Small Cars
To view the score table you'll need to have Adobe Acrobat installed on your computer. You may already have it, but if not, it can be downloaded for free from www.adobe.com

Close scores amongst the finalists illustrates the tight competition in this category.

While price will always be a critical consideration in this segment, the term "cheap and cheerful" and its downmarket connotation can be consigned to history. As cars across the board become more sophisticated, buyers are expecting similar improvements in the standard safety features and equipment levels of the average small car. Last year's winner Hyundai Getz and Holden's Barina are joined in the final three by a new entrant to the market, Ford Fiesta. All feature dual airbags, front seatbelt pre-tensioners and power steering. Power windows are standard on Fiesta and Barina, while Getz and Barina also come with standard air-conditioning.

In the final analysis Fiesta takes first place. At $14,490 the Fiesta's pricing slots it neatly between the Getz ($13,990) and Barina ($14,990). While it loses points against the Getz's generous warranty and lower operating costs and the Barina's thriftier fuel economy, the small Ford gains valuable ground in other key areas.

Matching the Barina in build and finish quality, the materials used in the Fiesta's interior have a more expensive look and feel, belying the car's price, while Hyundai's use of hard-looking plastics for the dashboard, steering wheel and door trims give the Getz interior a lacklustre character. Comfort also rated better in the Fiesta, the sports style seats offering good support while the Getz scored best for space. All three rate equally for ergonomics, offering well-laid-out cabins, having their switches and controls within easy reach and large clear instrumentation.

At 1.6 litres the Fiesta has the largest engine of the trio offering strong performance, although it is noisy under hard acceleration. By comparison the Barina's powerplant doesn't disgrace itself with its lively character, and while the Getz produces the same power as the Fiesta it lacks the mid-range urge of the Ford, meaning more work with the gears to keep momentum up.

Of all the areas under consideration, it is the chassis dynamics where the Ford has its most distinct advantage. Equipped with the largest wheels and tyres of the group, the Fiesta's handling is up there with best in class. Communicative steering and a wide footprint give the car a confident and competent feel. The Getz offers user-friendly handling but lacks the crispness of the Fiesta - although it equals the Ford in ride quality, while the Barina can't quite match the others.

As the new player in the field the Fiesta has raised the bar, but it speaks volumes for the others that they are finalists in a very close finish.

Top 5

Ford Fiesta LX 3D, Hyundai Getz GL 3D, Holden Barina 3D XC, Honda Jazz VTi, Toyota Echo 3D

Previous Results
2007 - VW Polo TDI
2006 - VW Polo TDI
2005 - Hyundai Getz
2004 - Ford Fiesta
2003 - Hyundai Getz
2002 - Renault Clio Expression
2001 - Hyundai Accent GL
2000 - Hyundai Accent GL

 
About Us | Contact Us | Auto Club Membership | Roadside Assistance | © 2008 ABC