Australia's Best Cars
Winners 2009 Previous Results Judging Criteria Judging Panel Your Say Media Login
Previous Results

Previous Results

2010 | 2009 | 2008 | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004 | 2003 | 2002 | 2001 | 2000



Best Recreational Vehicle Over $45,00

BMW X5 3.0i

BMW X5 3.0i
5-door wagon 3.0 litre
in-line 6-cylinder
$82,350


Value for Money
Importance
Pricing 3 Medium
Running & Repair 4 Low
Warranty 2 Low
Standard Features 4 Critical
Retained Value 5 High



Design & Function

 
Ergonomics 3 Critical
Innovation 4 Critical
Safety 5 Critical
Security 4 High
Comfort 4 Critical
Space & Practicality 4 High
Build & Finish Quality 4 Critical



On the Road

 
Fuel Efficency 3 Low
Performance 4 High
Ride 4 Critical
Handling & Steering 4 High
Braking 4 High
Smoothness/Quietness 5 Critical
4WD Ability 4 Medium



Overall Average


4.22



Key to Ratings

 
Well Above Average 5 .
Above Average 4 .
Average 3 .
Below Average 2 .
Well Below Average 1 .

Importance Weighting

 
Critical 1.00 .
High 0.80 .
Medium 0.60 .
Low 0.40 .



View Scores for all Rec. Vehicles > $45,000
To view the score table you'll need to have Adobe Acrobat installed on your computer. You may already have it, but if not, it can be downloaded for free from www.adobe.com

The recreational vehicle growth spurt shows no sign of slowing, and Australia's generous import concessions for off-road vehicles are an invitation car companies find hard to resist.

The latest trend is towards luxury crossover vehicles which are neither fully fledged 4WDs nor smaller recreational vehicles, hence this new Australia's Best Cars category this year.

BMW dubs its X5 a sports activity vehicle. Call it what you will; we call it a winner.

Although BMW offers who X5 models, the 3.0i is the more prudent choice over the V8-powered 4.4i version at $107,850.

The 3.0i (which can also be bought as a manual) has better pricing and running and repair costs than its big brother, but matches its class-leading residuals. Safety gets top marks and the other noteworthy feature is its ability to isolate occupants from mechanical noise.

But X5 also rates above-average in 14 other assessment categories.

Feature creatures can gloat about the standard kit, while boffins will have a ball exploring the array of standard techno aids.

X5 also has suprisingly good ground clearance for off-road exploits and a full-size spare tyre. But owners should be aware of grip limitations off-road, the lack of a low-range gear box and minimal engine braking.

BMW's two-year warranty is less than the industry standard and deserves a below-average-ranking.

And in terms of price, ergonomics and there are other flagbearers.

Among these is Subaru Outback H6, which is a more economical but smaller alternative. Better security would help the Subaru's cause, and it needs a performance boost and better off-road capabilities to topple the X5s.

The Volvo Cross Country is another to impress, courtesy of its resale values and effective use of space, but it's warranty and security are below par, and it lacks the ability to clear bigger bush bumps.

Previous Results
2004 - Ford Territory TX AWD*
(*Best Recreational 4WD)
2003 - Subaru Forester X*
(*Best Recreational 4WD)
2002 - BMW X5 3.0i*
(*Best Recreational 4WD)
2001 - BMW X5 3.0i
2000 - Subaru Forester Limited*
(*Best Recreational Vehicle)

 
About Us | Contact Us | Motoring Club Membership | Roadside Assistance | © 2008 ABC