Australia's Best Cars
Winners 2009 Previous Results Judging Criteria Judging Panel Your Say Media Login
Previous Results

Previous Results

2010 | 2009 | 2008 | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004 | 2003 | 2002 | 2001 | 2000



Best Mid-Size Car Under $25,000

Holden Astra City

Holden Astra City
5-door hatch 1.8 litre 4-cylinder
$20,220


Value for Money
Importance
Pricing 4 Critical
Running & Repair 4 High
Warranty 3 High
Standard Features 3 High
Retained Value 4 Medium



Design & Function

 
Ergonomics 3 High
Innovation 4 Medium
Safety 4 Critical
Security 3 High
Comfort 3 Medium
Space & Practicality 3 Medium
Build & Finish Quality 4 Medium



On the Road

 
Fuel Efficency 4 High
Performance 4 Medium
Ride 3 Medium
Handling & Steering 5 High
Braking 4 High
Smoothness/Quietness 5 Medium



Overall Average


3.73



Key to Ratings

 
Well Above Average 5 .
Above Average 4 .
Average 3 .
Below Average 2 .
Well Below Average 1 .

Importance Weighting

 
Critical 1.00 .
High 0.80 .
Medium 0.60 .
Low 0.40 .



View Scores for all Mid-Size Cars < $25,000
To view the score table you'll need to have Adobe Acrobat installed on your computer. You may already have it, but if not, it can be downloaded for free from www.adobe.com

The inclusion of four new contenders provided the foundation for a toughly fought battle in this category.

The likes of Daewoo Tecuma, Honda Civic, Hyundai Elantra and Nissan Pulsar Hatch stepped up the challenge, with Elantra and Pulsar posing up the biggest threat to last year's winner Holden Astra.

Hyundai Elantra GL, which finished this contest not far off the pace in second place, rates high in value for money, with price and warranty being it's strong points.

Also in Elantra's favour are vehicle security, space and practicality and ride quality. However, the Hyundai falls short in terms of running and repair costs, innovation, safety, build and finish quality, fuel efficency, handling and steering, braking, and smoothness/quietness.

Close on the heels of the Hyundai is the Nissan Pulsar ST Hatch, which to its credit scores consistently in 13 of the 18 judging criteria. Its strengths are pricing, standard features and ergonomics. However, space and practicality rate below average in its class.

But despite the challenge provided by new competitors in this field, Holden Astra City still puts in a strong performance, to repeat its victory in 2000 Australia's Best Cars.

Astra scores maximum points in two criteria - handling and steering, and smoothness and quietness - while achieving nine above average scores. Included among the latter are price and safety - both of which are deemed of critical importance by new car buyers. Additionally, running/repair costs, fuel efficiency and braking - regarded by buyers as being of high importance - score above average in each instance.

Unlike its competitors, Astra did not register a below average score in any area. However, in criteria that buyers consider being of high importance, such as warranty, standard features and ergonomics, Astra rates only average.

Previous Results

2007 - Honda Civic VTi
2006 - Honda Civic VTi
2005 - Ford Focus CL
2004 - VW Golf Trendline
2003 - Subaru Impreza GX
2002 - Holden Astra City
2001 - Holden Astra City
2000 - Holden Astra City

 
About Us | Contact Us | Motoring Club Membership | Roadside Assistance | © 2008 ABC