Australia's Best Cars
Winners 2009 Previous Results Judging Criteria Judging Panel Your Say Media Login
Previous Results

Previous Results

2008 | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004 | 2003 | 2002 | 2001 | 2000



Best Family Car

Holden Commodore Acclaim

Holden Commodore Acclaim
4-door sedan 3.8 litre V6
$36,390


Value for Money
Importance
Pricing 2 High
Running & Repair 4 High
Warranty 3 Medium
Standard Features 4 High
Retained Value 4 High



Design & Function

 
Ergonomics 4 High
Innovation 3 Low
Safety 4 Critical
Security 4 High
Comfort 4 Crtical
Space & Practicality 4 Critical
Build & Finish Quality 3 High



On the Road

 
Fuel Efficency 3 Medium
Performance 4 High
Ride 4 High
Handling & Steering 4 High
Braking 4 High
Smoothness/Quietness 3 High



Overall Average


3.66



Key to Ratings

 
Well Above Average 5 .
Above Average 4 .
Average 3 .
Below Average 2 .
Well Below Average 1 .

Importance Weighting

 
Critical 1.00 .
High 0.80 .
Medium 0.60 .
Low 0.40 .



View Scores for all Family Cars
To view the score table you'll need to have Adobe Acrobat installed on your computer. You may already have it, but if not, it can be downloaded for free from www.adobe.com

Holden's unstoppable 2001 sales momentum has already sewn up consecutive top-seller crowns. Part of the success rests with a resurgent four-cylinder range but there is no doubt that the best-selling car in Australia, Commodore, is Lion King for Holden.

In August this year, a subtly changed Series II VX model stalked into showrooms and clawed its rivals.

Unfortunately the facelift, and subsequent price rise, blotted Commodore's copybook. In a segment where a fistful of dollars separate fierce rivals, Commodore's price now means a below-average rating for the car.

But that scoring blemish is the end of the bad news. Commodore Acclaim gets 12 above-average scores in the remaining 17 categories, an indication of its ability to meet most family demands.

Most importantly, it's ranked above-average in the critically weighted family criteria: safety, comfort, and space and practicality.

Holden's decision to use anti-lock brakes across the Commodore range is an advantage in the base cars, but it leads the way even against foes with higher levels of equipment by offering optional side airbags, plus traction control as standard.

While Commodore generally rates well in safety, it has some catching up to do with it's competitors in terms of crash test results.

Ford Falcon Futura is the big mover this year, with a vastly improved safety showing spearheading its surge to second. But the Blue Oval's family class offering is still a car of highs and lows. While it returns class-leading scores for running and repair costs and performance, Futura scores below-average marks in retained value, innovation, fuel efficiency, and smoothness and quietness.

Rounding out the top three is Mitsubishi Magna Advance. Resale values are the only sore point, otherwise Magna is a viable option for family buyers, particularly for those who'll forego a bit of space for more refinement.

Previous Results
2004 - Ford BA Falcon Series II, XT
2003 - Ford Falcon XT
2002 - Ford Falcon Futura BA
2001 - Holden Commodore Acclaim
2000 - Holden Commodore Acclaim

 
About Us | Contact Us | Motoring Club Membership | Roadside Assistance | © 2008 ABC